← All 300 StayOdds Hotels
← All StayOdds Hotels / Los Angeles & Americas / The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
Global Directory Strong Consensus
New York City, United States •Rosewood

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

Kind, attentive and accommodating staff • Responsive technician and prompt assistance

92% StayOdds
90/100 StayOdds Index
Global Global Directory
9.2/10 Verified Guests (154)
Luxury Advisor VIP Perks Slot: Coming soon — book eligible 5-star stays with complimentary breakfast, resort credit & room upgrades.
Strong Consensus

Critics & Official Awards vs. Real Guest Score

Hype matches reality (-4 pts) — critics & real guests agree

-4 pts Opinion Gap
Critics & Official Awards88 / 100
Real Guest Score9.2 / 10.0 (92/100)

Key Hotel Facts & Decision Details

Strictly verified property specs, standout highlights, and honest watch-outs — blank fields are omitted rather than guessed.

Transfer LogisticsNearest airport code: LGA
Brand / CollectionRosewood
⚠ Aging Finish Noted
Standout Strengths

What Stands Out

Kind, attentive and accommodating staff • Responsive technician and prompt assistance

Watch-Outs

Know Before Booking

Serious cleanliness concern: guest diagnosed with scabies after stay • Hotel refused to provide inspection/documentation proving remediation

Dynamic StayOdds Formula

Global Directory

40% Sourced Critics & Awards (2+) • 60% Verified Guests

0%—First-Hand
40%88/100Critics & Awards
60%92/100Verified Guests

First-Hand 5-Axis Scorecard

Global Directory

The Uncharted Itinerary has not scored a full stay here yet. When filmed, our whole-number 5-axis scores will automatically merge into Tier 1.

Official Awards & Editorial Ratings

2 sourced
17/2085/100

The Carlyle still feels like a hotel rather than a lobby full of phones. Fat Favorite, scored 17/20 by Fat Voyage in New York, USA.

Linked YouTube Video Reviews

0 linked

No YouTube reviews linked yet. Creators are never attributed without a direct verified YouTube video URL.

Compare Nearby Luxury Stays

Explore other verified properties in Los Angeles & Americas.